With the Twins having all up wrapped up the division with a sweep over the White Sox in Chicago, it’s time to start looking toward the postseason. The Twins are nine games up in the AL Central race and just a 1/2 game back from the Rays for the best record in baseball. Homefield advantage is definitely something to strive for but if it costs the team by battering some of its core players when the division was already a foregone conclusion, is it really worth the fight?
Barring a monumental collapse, Minnesota will enter the postseason with no worse than the #2 seed, giving them homefield in the ALDS and possibly the ALCS, should they advance alongside the #3 seed. The Twins also enjoy the luxury of finishing the season against a slew of teams that are no better than .500 as of today while the Rays and Yankees battle each other and the ever-dangerous Red Sox several more times in September and October.
With that in mind, I think it’s time for Gardenhire to begin resting starters on a daily basis, starting with Michael Cuddyer. Since Morneau went down with a concussion in July, Cuddyer has played every game and the strain of picking up first base every day is starting to show in Mikey’s numbers. His OPS+ over July, August, and September are 134, 91, and 64. As Cuddyer is one of only two legitimate right-handed power threats on the team and that Minnesota may face any combination of Pettitte, Sabathia, Lee, and Price in the postseason, it seem obvious that Gardenhire needs to start working Cuddy out of the lineup on a regular basis as soon as possible to get him prepared to face some of the best left-handers in baseball in early October.
The question is: will he do it or will he push Cuddy in an attempt to gain homefield advantage throughout? Or, possibly, a more important question is: will Cuddyer even help the team at this point by continuing to post a .612 OPS in September?


